An Unexpected Reunion
Former spouses Kyle Cooke and Amanda Batula have sparked intense speculation among viewers after being spotted sharing a lighthearted moment together. The duo, who confirmed their separation back in January, were seen leaving a studio in New York City on Thursday, June 11, immediately following the wrap of the In the City reunion taping.
The images, which surfaced shortly after the event, depict the pair in high spirits. In one particular shot, the 43-year-old Cooke and 34-year-old Batula are seen laughing together, with Batula playfully reaching for Cooke’s hand. A second frame shows Cooke with his arm gently around Batula’s back, fueling further chatter among the show's loyal fanbase.
Fan Backlash and Skepticism
The public response to these photos has been largely polarized, with many viewers taking to social media to voice their concerns. Critics have labeled the interaction as performative, with some suggesting that the behavior is part of a larger, potentially manipulative dynamic.
One social media user noted: «I can tell that it’s staged but there isn’t enough promo in the world that would make me excuse this. If he takes her back, I’m done. Protecting Amanda has long been one of Kyle’s control tactics.»
Other commenters echoed similar sentiments, questioning the sincerity of the interaction. Observers pointed to Cooke’s historically protective nature over Batula, suggesting that such displays may be rooted in underlying guilt rather than genuine friendship.
Context of the Relationship
The stir caused by these photos comes shortly after the conclusion of the Summer House reunion. During the three-part special, which wrapped up on June 9, the cast confronted Batula and West Wilson regarding their burgeoning romance, which had reportedly developed away from the public eye. Batula and Wilson went public with their relationship on March 31, a move that notably impacted the group dynamic, particularly given Wilson's past connection with former cast member Ciara Miller.
During the reunion, Cooke did not mince words regarding his feelings toward the situation. He openly expressed his sense of betrayal by Wilson, citing the shift from being close friends to feeling that Wilson had taken advantage of Batula during a period of vulnerability. Despite the heated exchange, Wilson stated at the conclusion of the broadcast: «I hope that one day probably not all of these friendships will be mended but I do hope some of them can be. That’s a main priority.»